# Latticra Runtime Boundary Refinement Implementation Status: runtime boundary refinement implementation with Lat pipeline clause, declaration, module/count, stage-summary, parse-error, semantic-error, downstream-stage-error, span, comment, Lat LIR module-summary, Lat LIR module label, Lat LIR source-span, Lat LIR node-kind, Lat LIR first-node, Lat LIR first-node topology, Lat LIR first-node span, Lat LIR first transition-node, Lat LIR first transition-node topology, Lat LIR first transition-node span, Lat LIR first-edge, Lat LIR first-edge endpoint, Lat LIR first-edge endpoint payload, Lat LIR first-edge endpoint topology, Lat LIR first-edge span, Lat LIR first transition-source edge, Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint, Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint payload, Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint topology, Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint span, Lat LIR first transition-source edge span, Lat LIR no-effect, and Lat LIR edge-kind evidence Scope: no-effect runtime-boundary evidence reporting for Lat pipeline metadata, Lat pipeline first-clause metadata, Lat pipeline first-declaration metadata, Lat pipeline module/count metadata, Lat pipeline stage-summary metadata, Lat pipeline parse-error metadata, Lat pipeline semantic-error metadata, Lat pipeline downstream stage-error metadata, Lat pipeline span metadata, Lat pipeline line-comment metadata, Lat-specific LIR module-summary metadata, Lat-specific LIR module label metadata, Lat-specific LIR source-span metadata, Lat-specific LIR node-kind metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-node metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-node topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-node span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint payload metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint payload metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge span metadata, Lat-specific LIR no-effect metadata, and Lat-specific LIR edge-kind metadata. ## Purpose This implementation slice refines the runtime boundary so it can classify and report Lat pipeline evidence and Lat-specific LIR evidence without executing Lat, executing LIR, mutating state, performing I/O, opening network connections, touching hardware, or enabling runtime behavior. The implementation follows: ```text docs/RUNTIME_BOUNDARY_REFINEMENT_PLAN.md ``` ## Added / changed files ```text include/latticra/runtime_boundary.h src/runtime_boundary.c tests/runtime_boundary_lat_pipeline_evidence.c docs/RUNTIME_BOUNDARY_REFINEMENT_IMPLEMENTATION.md ``` The existing runtime boundary test runner automatically includes the new invariant file: ```text scripts/test-runtime-boundary.sh ``` ## Public API refinement The runtime boundary request now accepts optional Lat pipeline metadata: ```text const latticra_lat_pipeline_result_t *lat_pipeline ``` The runtime boundary request kinds now include: ```text LATTICRA_RUNTIME_BOUNDARY_LAT_PIPELINE_VALIDATE ``` The runtime boundary record now carries no-effect evidence fields for: ```text lat_pipeline_status lat_pipeline_error lat_pipeline_parse_error lat_pipeline_span_start_offset lat_pipeline_span_end_offset lat_pipeline_span_start_line lat_pipeline_span_start_column lat_pipeline_span_end_line lat_pipeline_span_end_column lat_pipeline_semantic_error lat_pipeline_model_error lat_pipeline_lowering_error lat_pipeline_lir_error lat_pipeline_last_completed_stage lat_pipeline_failed_stage lat_pipeline_parse_ok lat_pipeline_semantic_ok lat_pipeline_model_ok lat_pipeline_lowering_ok lat_pipeline_lir_ok lat_pipeline_no_effect_chain_ok lat_pipeline_evidence_level lat_pipeline_semantic_valid lat_pipeline_module_name lat_pipeline_source_len lat_pipeline_declaration_count lat_pipeline_clause_count lat_pipeline_model_declaration_count lat_pipeline_model_clause_count lat_pipeline_first_declaration_node_index lat_pipeline_first_declaration_kind lat_pipeline_first_declaration_name lat_pipeline_first_declaration_source lat_pipeline_first_declaration_parse_index lat_pipeline_first_declaration_first_clause_index lat_pipeline_first_declaration_clause_count lat_pipeline_first_declaration_source_index lat_pipeline_first_transition_source_index lat_pipeline_first_clause_node_index lat_pipeline_first_clause_role lat_pipeline_first_clause_effect lat_pipeline_first_clause_name lat_pipeline_first_clause_operator lat_pipeline_first_clause_value lat_pipeline_node_count lat_pipeline_edge_count lat_pipeline_comment_count lat_pipeline_first_comment_start_offset lat_pipeline_first_comment_end_offset lat_pipeline_first_comment_start_line lat_pipeline_first_comment_start_column lat_pipeline_first_comment_end_line lat_pipeline_first_comment_end_column lat_lir_source_kind lat_lir_module_name lat_lir_card_name lat_lir_effect lat_lir_boundary lat_lir_report_classification lat_lir_shape_kind lat_lir_span_start_offset lat_lir_span_end_offset lat_lir_span_start_line lat_lir_span_start_column lat_lir_span_end_line lat_lir_span_end_column lat_lir_module_node_count lat_lir_module_edge_count lat_lir_binding_count lat_lir_text_count lat_lir_lat_state_node_count lat_lir_lat_policy_node_count lat_lir_lat_transition_node_count lat_lir_lat_assertion_node_count lat_lir_lat_requirement_node_count lat_lir_lat_effect_declaration_node_count lat_lir_has_first_lat_node lat_lir_first_lat_node_index lat_lir_first_lat_node_kind lat_lir_first_lat_node_name lat_lir_first_lat_node_value lat_lir_first_lat_node_operator lat_lir_first_lat_node_binding lat_lir_first_lat_node_parent_index lat_lir_first_lat_node_first_child_index lat_lir_first_lat_node_child_count lat_lir_first_lat_node_span_start_offset lat_lir_first_lat_node_span_end_offset lat_lir_first_lat_node_span_start_line lat_lir_first_lat_node_span_start_column lat_lir_first_lat_node_span_end_line lat_lir_first_lat_node_span_end_column lat_lir_has_first_transition_node lat_lir_first_transition_node_index lat_lir_first_transition_node_kind lat_lir_first_transition_node_name lat_lir_first_transition_node_value lat_lir_first_transition_node_operator lat_lir_first_transition_node_binding lat_lir_first_transition_node_parent_index lat_lir_first_transition_node_first_child_index lat_lir_first_transition_node_child_count lat_lir_first_transition_node_span_start_offset lat_lir_first_transition_node_span_end_offset lat_lir_first_transition_node_span_start_line lat_lir_first_transition_node_span_start_column lat_lir_first_transition_node_span_end_line lat_lir_first_transition_node_span_end_column lat_lir_no_effect_chain_ok lat_lir_evidence_level lat_lir_no_effect lat_lir_execution_allowed lat_lir_mutation_allowed lat_lir_server_allowed lat_lir_network_allowed lat_lir_recovery_allowed lat_lir_hardware_allowed lat_lir_contains_edge_count lat_lir_binds_edge_count lat_lir_annotates_edge_count lat_lir_orders_before_edge_count lat_lir_transition_edge_count lat_lir_has_first_edge lat_lir_first_edge_index lat_lir_first_edge_from_index lat_lir_first_edge_to_index lat_lir_first_edge_kind lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_kind lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_name lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_value lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_operator lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_binding lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_parent_index lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_first_child_index lat_lir_first_edge_from_node_child_count lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_kind lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_name lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_value lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_operator lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_binding lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_parent_index lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_first_child_index lat_lir_first_edge_to_node_child_count lat_lir_first_edge_span_start_offset lat_lir_first_edge_span_end_offset lat_lir_first_edge_span_start_line lat_lir_first_edge_span_start_column lat_lir_first_edge_span_end_line lat_lir_first_edge_span_end_column lat_lir_has_first_transition_source_edge lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_kind lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_kind lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_name lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_value lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_operator lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_binding lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_parent_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_first_child_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_child_count lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_span_start_offset lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_span_end_offset lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_span_start_line lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_span_start_column lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_span_end_line lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_from_node_span_end_column lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_kind lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_name lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_value lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_operator lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_binding lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_parent_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_first_child_index lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_child_count lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_span_start_offset lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_span_end_offset lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_span_start_line lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_span_start_column lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_span_end_line lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_to_node_span_end_column lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_span_start_offset lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_span_end_offset lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_span_start_line lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_span_start_column lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_span_end_line lat_lir_first_transition_source_edge_span_end_column lat_lir_has_lat_state_nodes lat_lir_has_lat_transition_nodes lat_lir_has_transition_source_edges ``` ## Behavior The new `lat-pipeline-validate` request is allowed only when: ```text mode == validation-only requested effect is none or read authority metadata is present and no-effect Lat pipeline metadata is present and OK Lat pipeline semantic_valid is true Lat pipeline no-effect flags are preserved ``` Failed Lat pipeline metadata is denied with the closest existing runtime-boundary denial label: ```text parse_not_ok -> parser-failed semantic_not_ok / semantic_not_valid -> semantic-failed no_effect_violation -> non-no-effect-flags other pipeline failure -> lir-failed ``` Lat execution and LIR execution remain future-gated. ## Report surface `latticra_runtime_boundary_report` now includes deterministic report fields for Lat pipeline evidence, Lat pipeline first-clause evidence, Lat pipeline first-declaration evidence, Lat pipeline module/count evidence, Lat pipeline stage-summary evidence, Lat pipeline parse-error evidence, Lat pipeline semantic-error evidence, Lat pipeline downstream stage-error evidence, Lat pipeline span evidence, Lat pipeline line-comment evidence, Lat-specific LIR module-summary evidence, Lat-specific LIR module label evidence, Lat-specific LIR source-span evidence, Lat-specific LIR node-kind evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-node evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-node topology evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-node span evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node topology evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node span evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-edge evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint payload evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint topology evidence, Lat-specific LIR first-edge span evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint payload evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint topology evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint span evidence, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge span evidence, Lat-specific LIR no-effect evidence, and Lat-specific LIR edge-kind evidence. `LATTICRA_RUNTIME_BOUNDARY_REPORT_MAX` is increased to 16384 bytes to preserve bounded output with the expanded report surface. ## Validation Run: ```sh sh scripts/test-runtime-boundary.sh ``` The focused evidence tests verify: ```text runtime_boundary_allows_valid_lat_pipeline_metadata runtime_boundary_denies_failed_lat_pipeline_metadata runtime_boundary_denies_parse_failed_lat_pipeline_metadata runtime_boundary_denies_model_failed_lat_pipeline_metadata runtime_boundary_reports_lat_pipeline_evidence runtime_boundary_keeps_lat_lir_execution_future_gated ``` The Lat pipeline evidence invariants also verify that parser error metadata, semantic error metadata, downstream model/lowering/LIR error metadata, first-clause metadata, first-declaration metadata, module/count metadata, stage-summary metadata, parser diagnostic/module span metadata, line-comment count, first-comment span metadata, Lat-specific LIR module-summary metadata, Lat-specific LIR module label metadata, Lat-specific LIR source-span metadata, Lat-specific LIR node-kind counts, Lat-specific LIR first-node identity, Lat-specific LIR first-node topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-node span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node identity, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-node span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge identity, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint payload metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge endpoint topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first-edge span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge identity, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint payload metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint topology metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge endpoint span metadata, Lat-specific LIR first transition-source edge span metadata, Lat-specific LIR no-effect flags, and Lat-specific LIR edge-kind counts are copied into runtime-boundary records and reports, including denied records for failed Lat pipeline metadata. ## Compatibility This refinement preserves existing runtime boundary behavior for: ```text parse-only validate-only classify-only render-report nucleus-task-report lat-validate lir-validate authority-check future-gated operational request kinds unknown request denial unknown effect denial operator confirmation non-override behavior small-buffer behavior Lat pipeline parse-error evidence reporting Lat pipeline semantic-error evidence reporting Lat pipeline downstream stage-error evidence reporting Lat pipeline first-clause evidence reporting Lat pipeline first-declaration evidence reporting Lat pipeline module/count evidence reporting Lat pipeline stage-summary evidence reporting Lat pipeline diagnostic/module span evidence reporting Lat pipeline line-comment evidence reporting Lat LIR module-summary evidence reporting Lat LIR module label evidence reporting Lat LIR source-span evidence reporting Lat LIR node-kind evidence reporting Lat LIR first-node evidence reporting Lat LIR first-node topology evidence reporting Lat LIR first-node span evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-node evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-node topology evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-node span evidence reporting Lat LIR first-edge evidence reporting Lat LIR first-edge endpoint evidence reporting Lat LIR first-edge endpoint payload evidence reporting Lat LIR first-edge endpoint topology evidence reporting Lat LIR first-edge span evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-source edge evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint payload evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint topology evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-source edge endpoint span evidence reporting Lat LIR first transition-source edge span evidence reporting Lat LIR no-effect evidence reporting Lat LIR edge-kind evidence reporting denied Lat pipeline comment evidence recording ``` ## Boundary This implementation does not provide runtime behavior, command execution, Lat execution, LIR execution, task effect execution, live movement, state mutation, file I/O, network I/O, server interaction, self-update, recovery behavior, rollback, hardware support, boot behavior, terminal control, security isolation, sandboxing, malware prevention, ransomware prevention, certification, accreditation, or operating-system completeness.