# openSUSE RPM Build-Evidence Intake Denial Review Contract Status: active RPM build-evidence intake denial review contract Scope: define review of denied openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake while the validation promotion blocker matrix is closed. ## Purpose This contract records the no-effect review of denied openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake. The goal is narrow: a denied build-evidence intake request cannot be re-requested, reopened, summarized as accepted, or used to open an openSUSE build lane while the validation promotion blocker matrix remains blocked. This contract is documentation-only and static. It does not run `rpmbuild`, run `osc`, run `rpmlint`, request build evidence, re-request denied evidence, accept build evidence, create RPM artifacts, inspect RPM artifacts, install packages, remove packages, publish packages, submit Latticra to openSUSE, accept Open Build Service evidence, promote validation results, or claim package readiness. ## Current Denial Review State ```text opensuse_rpm_build_evidence_intake_denial_review_contract_present=1 rpm_build_evidence_intake_denial_review_contract_present=1 build_evidence_intake_denial_review_state=reviewed-upheld-no-effect build_evidence_intake_denial_state=denied-no-effect validation_promotion_blocker_matrix_state=blocked-no-effect opensuse_rpm_build_gate_state=closed-no-effect denial_review_required_before_re_request=1 denial_review_present=1 denial_review_decision=uphold-denial denial_re_request_allowed=0 opensuse_build_evidence_intake_allowed=0 opensuse_build_evidence_intake_denied=1 opensuse_platform_build_evidence_accepted=0 build_transcript_intake_accepted=0 rpm_build_transcript_intake_accepted=0 rpm_build_lane_opened=0 opensuse_single_platform_build_lane_opened=0 source_archive_accepted_for_build=0 accepted_rpmlint_transcript_present=0 environment_transcript_present=0 explicit_operator_build_authorization=0 rpm_artifact_created=0 rpm_artifact_sha256_recorded=0 rpm_payload_accepted=0 rpm_install_remove_transcript_present=0 obs_publication_non_claim_review_present=1 rpm_validation_result_promoted=0 opensuse_rpm_validation_result_promoted=0 package_readiness_claimed=0 ``` ## Review Record Requirements A future denial review record must bind the review to the denied intake request: ```text build_evidence_intake_request_identifier build_evidence_denial_reference denial_review_identifier opensuse_target_distribution requested_build_evidence_kind requested_build_command submitted_transcript_reference validation_promotion_blocker_matrix_reference denial_review_decision denial_review_reason denial_review_reviewer status_page_update_reference operator_authorization_reference ``` The only current review decision allowed by this contract is `uphold-denial`. ## openSUSE Denial Review Current openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial review upholds denial: ```text opensuse_build_evidence_intake_denial_review_present=1 opensuse_build_evidence_intake_denial_upheld=1 opensuse_denial_re_request_allowed=0 opensuse_build_evidence_intake_allowed=0 opensuse_build_evidence_intake_denied=1 opensuse_build_transcript_intake_accepted=0 opensuse_platform_build_evidence_accepted=0 opensuse_rpmbuild_evidence_accepted=0 opensuse_osc_build_evidence_accepted=0 opensuse_rpmlint_evidence_accepted=0 opensuse_source_rpm_evidence_accepted=0 opensuse_binary_rpm_evidence_accepted=0 rpmbuild_run=0 rpmbuild_ba_run=0 rpmbuild_bb_run=0 rpmbuild_bs_run=0 osc_build_run=0 rpmlint_run=0 osc_submitreq_run=0 obs_build_result_claimed=0 opensuse_obs_publication_claimed=0 opensuse_rpm_validation_result_promoted=0 opensuse_distribution_ready=0 ``` openSUSE build, lint, artifact, payload, install/remove, OBS, submit-request, and official-package evidence remains denied, unaccepted, and unusable as build-lane opening evidence. ## Current Blockers Denial review remains an upheld no-effect denial under this blocker state: ```text validation_promotion_blocker_matrix_state=blocked-no-effect source_archive_accepted_for_build=0 accepted_rpmlint_transcript_present=0 environment_transcript_present=0 explicit_operator_build_authorization=0 rpm_artifact_created=0 rpm_artifact_sha256_recorded=0 rpm_payload_accepted=0 rpm_install_remove_transcript_present=0 opensuse_platform_build_evidence_accepted=0 rpm_validation_result_promoted=0 denial_re_request_allowed=0 ``` ## Command Boundary This contract does not: ```text run rpmbuild run osc build run rpmlint run osc branch run osc commit run osc submitreq request build evidence re-request build evidence accept build evidence create RPM artifacts inspect RPM artifacts install RPM packages remove RPM packages create an Open Build Service project create an Open Build Service package publish RPM artifacts submit Latticra to openSUSE promote openSUSE validation results claim package readiness ``` ## Relationship To Existing Lanes This contract depends on: ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPMLINT_FINDINGS_CLASSIFICATION.md docs/OPENSUSE_SOURCE_ARCHIVE_REPRODUCIBILITY_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_SOURCE_ARCHIVE_FIXTURE_LANE.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_TOPDIR_HANDOFF_LANE.md docs/OPENSUSE_LOCAL_RPM_BUILD_GATE_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_LOCAL_RPM_BUILD_ENVIRONMENT_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_ARTIFACT_NAMING_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_PAYLOAD_INSPECTION_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_INSTALL_REMOVE_TRANSCRIPT_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_OBS_PUBLICATION_NON_CLAIM_REVIEW_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_VALIDATION_PROMOTION_BLOCKER_MATRIX_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_CONTRACT.md docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CONTRACT.md ``` The local RPM build gate remains closed. This denial review contract only records that the denied intake state was reviewed and upheld while the blocker matrix remains closed. ## Next Slice Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition contract: ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-contract.yml ``` That lane closes the upheld denial without accepting openSUSE build evidence or opening RPM builds. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout contract: ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-contract.yml ``` That lane closes out the no-effect disposition while keeping archive, re-request, build, and readiness blockers in place. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate contract: ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.yml ``` That lane keeps the closed-out denial unarchived while archive, re-request, build, and readiness blockers stay in place. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review contract before any archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-contract.yml ``` That lane reviews and upholds the closed archive gate while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition contract before any reviewed archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-contract.yml ``` That lane disposes the reviewed closed archive gate while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition can be archived or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-contract.yml ``` That lane closes out the reviewed archive gate disposition while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout can be archived or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.yml ``` That lane keeps the reviewed archive gate disposition closeout unarchived while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-contract.yml ``` That lane reviews and upholds the reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-contract.yml ``` That lane records the reviewed closeout archive gate as disposed while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition can be archived or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-contract.yml ``` That lane closes out the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout can be archived or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.yml ``` That lane keeps the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition closeout unarchived while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-contract.yml ``` That lane reviews and upholds the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-contract.yml ``` That lane records the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review as disposed while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition can be archived or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-contract.yml ``` That lane closes out the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate contract: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout can be archived or re-requested. ``` ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_CONTRACT.md scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.sh .github/workflows/opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-review-disposition-closeout-archive-gate-contract.yml ``` That lane keeps the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout unarchived while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Recommended next slice: ```text Add openSUSE RPM build-evidence intake denial disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review contract before any reviewed archive gate disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate review disposition closeout archive gate can be relaxed or re-requested. ``` That future lane should review the closed archive gate for the reviewed closeout archive gate review disposition closeout while preserving RPM build and readiness blockers. Completed follow-on archive gate review record: ```text docs/OPENSUSE_RPM_BUILD_EVIDENCE_INTAKE_DENIAL_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_DISPOSITION_CLOSEOUT_ARCHIVE_GATE_REVIEW_CONTRACT.md ``` That follow-on review preserves the closed, no-effect archive gate posture and does not accept build evidence, create RPM artifacts, or claim package readiness. ## Validation Run: ```sh sh scripts/test-opensuse-rpm-build-evidence-intake-denial-review-contract.sh ``` Expected output: ```text opensuse_rpm_build_evidence_intake_denial_review_contract: ok ```